Affiliate Disclosure: Links on this page may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate policy
Witch P.I. Mystery Books in Order
Below you'll find the complete list of Witch P.I. Mystery books in publication order. This is generally the recommended reading order for the series.
Reading order verified: April 2026
Quick Answer
What order should I read the Witch P.I. Mystery series? Start with "Witch Is When It All Began" (2015) and follow publication order through all 54 books.
The complete Witch P.I. Mystery reading order is listed below in publication sequence.
Publication Order
Witch Is When It All Began
2015
Witch Is When Life Got Complicated
2015
Witch Is When Everything Went Crazy
2015
Witch Is When Things Fell Apart
2015
Witch is When The Bubble Burst
2015
Witch Is When The Penny Dropped
2015
We Witch You a Merry Christmas
2015
Witch Is When The Floodgates Opened
2016
Witch Is When The Hammer Fell
2016
Witch Is When My Heart Broke
2016
Witch is When I Said Goodbye
2016
Witch Is When Stuff Got Serious
2016
Witch Is When All Was Revealed
2016
Witch Is Why Time Stood Still
2016
Witch Is Why the Laughter Stopped
2016
Witch Is Why Another Door Opened
2016
Witch Is Why Two Became One
2017
Witch Is Why The Moon Disappeared
2017
Witch Is Why The Wolf Howled
2017
Witch Is Why The Music Stopped
2017
Witch Is Why The Owl Returned
2017
Witch Is Why A Pin Dropped
2017
Witch Is Why The Search Began
2017
Witch Is Why Promises Were Broken
2017
Witch Is Why It Was Over
2018
Witch is How Things Had Changed
2018
Witch Is How Berries Tasted Good
2018
Witch Is How The Mirror Lied
2018
Witch is How The Tables Turned
2018
Witch is How The Drought Ended
2019
Witch is How The Dice Fell
2019
Witch Is How The Biscuits Disappeared
2019
Witch Is How Dreams Became Reality
2019
Witch is How Bells Were Saved
2019
Witch Is How To Fool Cats
2019
Witch is How To Lose Big
2020
Witch is How Life Changed Forever
2020
Witch Is Where Magic Lives Now
2020
Witch Is Where Clowns Go To Die
2020
Witch Is Where Squirrels Go Nuts
2021
Witch Is Where Rainbows End
2021
Witch Is Where Unicorns Cry
2021
Witch Is Where The Lights Went Out
2022
Witch Is Where Fairies Wing It
2022
Witch Is Where Roses Bloom Early
2022
Witch Is Where Decisions Are Made
2023
Witch Is Where Gnomes Rule
2023
Witch Is Where Cats Always Win
2023
Witch Is Where Chickens Go To Roost
2024
Witch Is The Nest Now Empty
2024
Witch Is The Hardest Pill To Swallow
2025
Witch Is The Joke No One Got
2025
Witch Is The Lamest Excuse Ever
2026
Witch Is The Enemy Of Magic
2026
Affiliate Disclosure
As an Amazon Associate, Reading Order Books earns from qualifying purchases. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you. This helps us maintain the site and continue providing reading order guides. Read our full disclosure